The film is set in New York City in the 1950s, and its central character is Lionel Essrog, played by Norton. Lionel is a private detective with Tourette syndrome, a neurological disorder characterized by repetitive movements or vocalizations known as tics. Lionel’s tics include sudden head jerks, grunts, and utterances of random phrases.
The movie’s plot revolves around Lionel’s investigation into the murder of his friend and mentor, Frank Minna, played by Bruce Willis. Minna was the boss of a detective agency, and Lionel and his colleagues are hired to investigate a case involving corruption in the city’s housing development projects.
As Lionel delves deeper into the case, he uncovers a web of conspiracies, betrayals, and cover-ups that involve powerful politicians, real estate developers, and organized crime. The more Lionel uncovers, the more dangerous and threatening the situation becomes, putting him and those around him in grave danger.
“Motherless Brooklyn” is not just a crime story but also a character-driven drama that explores themes of identity, justice, and empowerment. Lionel’s Tourette syndrome is not just a gimmick but an integral part of his character, as he struggles to find acceptance and respect in a world that cannot understand his condition. His condition also gives him a unique perspective on the world, allowing him to see beyond the surface and uncover hidden truths.
At the same time, the film also portrays the simmering tensions between the city’s various communities, including African Americans, Puerto Ricans, and Jews, and the ways in which they are exploited and marginalized by those in power. The film’s setting of 1950s New York also allows it to explore the era’s social and political issues, such as racial discrimination, urban renewal, and gentrification.
The film’s performances are its strongest point. Norton’s portrayal of Lionel is nuanced and empathetic, capturing the complexity of his character’s condition and his quest for justice. Mbatha-Raw delivers a nuanced performance as Laura Rose, a lawyer and activist who becomes Lionel’s ally and love interest. Baldwin is suitably menacing as a corrupt politician, while Dafoe is enigmatic as a reclusive architect who holds the key to the case.
The film’s visuals are also impressive, with the cinematography capturing the grittiness and vibrancy of 1950s New York. The film’s jazz-infused score by Daniel Pemberton adds to the film’s atmosphere, evoking the era’s music and culture.
Despite its many strengths, the film is not without its flaws. Its plot can be convoluted and confusing at times, with too many characters and subplots vying for attention. The film’s pacing can also be uneven, with some scenes feeling unnecessarily prolonged while others feel rushed.
Overall, “Motherless Brooklyn” is a well-crafted and thought-provoking film that is worth watching for its performances, visuals, and themes. It is a stylish and engaging crime thriller that also has something important to say about society and humanity. The film’s message is clear: in a world full of corruption and deception, justice and truth can only be found by those who are willing to fight for them.