The film follows the story of Otis, a young actor played by Noah Jupe, and his experiences of growing up in the spotlight, working with his father James, played by Shia LaBeouf. As a child, Otis is already strained by his father’s volatile and abusive behaviour but remains almost completely dependent on him as his manager and support system. As the film progresses, we see Otis develop into a troubled adolescent and young adult, grappling with the emotional neglect, physical and emotional abuse and trauma he has experienced.
The film’s exploration of the child star phenomenon is one of its most fascinating aspects. As Otis is forced to constantly perform in front of the camera, he is denied the chance to have a normal childhood at home or in school. It forces him to confront the highs and lows of fame, often portraying the most difficult moments of his life without any privacy. The almost surreal and suffocating confines of the film studio alternate with dreamscape scenes of futuristic landscapes, suggesting the more abstract and ephemeral nature of Otis’ experiences.
While the film is mostly concerned with the turmoil of Otis, the performances and chemistry between LaBeouf and Jupe are remarkable. LaBeouf is striking in his uncanny portrayal of an abusive and damaged father, capturing the character’s sheer desperation and inner turmoil, while also imbuing James with a certain vulnerability and empathy that makes the character more complex than we may initially expect. Jupe’s Otis, on the other hand, is a tender, affable and fragile performance that makes us all the more empathetic to his struggles for validation, love and acceptance.
Despite the film’s difficult and emotionally heavy subject material, “Honey Boy” never loses its sense of empathy or its nuance. It avoids easy answers or statements of catharsis, refusing to neatly wrapped up its characters in a bow. Rather, it encourages us to contemplate the multitude of factors that have led to Otis’ emotional state, without ever demonizing or excusing his father’s negative behaviour. Instead, we get the complex and often messy portrait of a family that exists in multiple shades of grey.
Overall, “Honey Boy” is a masterful work of art, blazing a new trail in exploring the child actor phenomenon and the trauma they can face both on and off-screen. With incredible performances, compelling writing and direction that is both introspective and innovative, it is a must-see film for anyone interested in the complexities of family dynamics, emotional trauma and the human experience. In LaBeouf’s words: “It’s therapy, but it’s cinematic.”