21 
0 
Nestled between the forks of Long Island, New York, lies a hidden gem that offers a perfect escape from the bustling city life – Shelter Island. Consisting of just 9.6 square miles, this small island is packed with natural beauty, serene beaches, and a plethora of attractions that make it a must-visit destination. Let’s delve into the top 10 attractions that you simply cannot miss when exploring Shelter Island.
1. Sunset Beach
Kick off your Shelter Island adventure by visiting Sunset Beach, a popular destination for locals and tourists alike. Relax in a hammock, sip on a cocktail, and enjoy stunning views of the sunset as you soak up the island vibes. With live music and a vibrant atmosphere, this beach is the perfect spot to unwind.
2. Mashomack Preserve
For nature enthusiasts, a visit to Mashomack Preserve is a must. Covering over 2,000 acres, this nature reserve offers breathtaking hikes through diverse habitats, including woodlands, salt marshes, and tidal creeks. Keep an eye out for the unique bird species that call this preserve home.
3. Sylvester Manor Educational Farm
Step back in time and discover the history of Shelter Island at the Sylvester Manor Educational Farm. This 17th-century plantation offers guided tours that delve into the island’s past, showcasing its farming history and enlightening visitors about the significance of agriculture in the local community.
4. Shelter Island Historical Society
Continue your journey through Shelter Island’s history by visiting the Shelter Island Historical Society. Explore the museum’s exhibits, which include artifacts, photographs, and documents that showcase the island’s development, from its Native American roots to its prominent role in the whaling industry.
5. Shell Beach
Known for its pristine coastline, Shelter Island offers several beautiful beaches, and Shell Beach is a standout. This secluded beach boasts calm waters, perfect for swimming and beachcombing. Take a leisurely stroll and collect unique seashells and rocks washed up by the gentle waves.
6. Dering Harbor
Nestled on the island’s north side, Dering Harbor is a picturesque village that offers stunning views of Gardiners Bay. Take a walk along the marina and admire the collection of boats, or enjoy a picnic in the serene waterfront park.
7. Crescent Beach
A visit to Shelter Island wouldn’t be complete without exploring Crescent Beach. This long, sandy shoreline is ideal for sunbathing, swimming, and picnicking. Don’t miss the opportunity to take a walk along the beach during low tide and witness an extraordinary view of Shelter Island Sound.
8. Picozzi’s Bike Shop
Rent a bicycle from Picozzi’s Bike Shop and embark on an adventurous exploration of Shelter Island’s scenic landscape. Pedal through tree-lined roads, explore hidden coves, and discover charming neighborhoods at your leisure.
9. Shelter Island Craft Brewery
After a day of sightseeing, visit the Shelter Island Craft Brewery to relax and sample the island’s finest brews. Take a guided tour of the facilities and learn about the beer-making process while enjoying a refreshing pint in the cozy taproom.
10. Gardiners Bay Country Club
Golf enthusiasts will delight in playing a round at Gardiners Bay Country Club. This picturesque 9-hole golf course offers stunning views of the bay and provides a challenging experience for both novice and experienced golfers.
Shelter Island offers a unique blend of natural beauty, historical significance, and laid-back charm. With its wealth of attractions, it is easy to see why this small island has become a sought-after destination for those seeking tranquility and serenity. Whether you are a nature lover, history buff, or simply in search of a relaxing getaway, Shelter Island has something for everyone. Explore these top 10 attractions and let the island’s hidden treasures captivate you.
0 | 
0