A Guide to the Best Eateries in Nantucket for 2019

Nantucket, widely known for its picturesque beaches and stunning sunsets, is also a foodie’s paradise. With its rich culinary tradition, the island offers a plethora of dining options to satisfy every palate. From fresh seafood to innovative farm-to-table dishes, Nantucket harbors a treasure trove of eateries that will leave you craving for more. Here is a guide to the best eateries on this enchanting island for 2019.

Straight Wharf Restaurant is a must-visit for seafood enthusiasts. Located on the town’s historic waterfront, this iconic restaurant offers breathtaking views of the harbor, creating the perfect backdrop for an unforgettable dining experience. With a focus on seasonal ingredients and a diverse menu that caters to all dietary preferences, Straight Wharf Restaurant is known for its impeccable seafood dishes, such as the lobster roll and seared Atlantic halibut.

For those looking for a unique dining experience, The Chanticleer is an exquisite destination. Tucked away in Siasconset village, this charming restaurant is known for its elegant ambiance and impeccable service. The Chanticleer’s menu presents a blend of traditional and contemporary cuisine, highlighting the island’s local produce. Standout dishes include the Pan Roasted Nantucket Fluke and the Organic Roasted Chicken.

To experience the farm-to-table movement at its finest, Proprietors Nantucket is the place to be. With a commitment to sourcing ingredients from local farms and purveyors, this restaurant crafts innovative and delicious dishes that celebrate Nantucket’s robust culinary scene. Uniquely designed cocktails, like their famous Beetnik, perfectly complement their seasonal menu. Proprietors Nantucket is a true gem that should not be missed.

If you find yourself in the mood for Italian cuisine, Ventuno is the perfect spot. This cozy eatery offers a menu influenced by the simplicity of Italian cooking, using the finest ingredients the island has to offer. With handmade pasta and wood-fired pizzas as their specialties, Ventuno captures the essence of Italian comfort food. Don’t forget to try their homemade gelato for a sweet ending to your meal.

For a more casual dining experience, Black-Eyed Susan’s is a must-visit. A favorite among locals and visitors alike, this charming bistro-style restaurant offers a cozy atmosphere and a creative menu. With an emphasis on fresh and local ingredients, Black-Eyed Susan’s excels in creating flavorful dishes, such as their famous Stuffed French Toast and Crab Cakes Benedict. Be prepared for a wait, as this hidden gem tends to fill up quickly.

Last but not least, if you’re craving sushi, Lola 41 is the place to be. Located in the heart of downtown Nantucket, this vibrant restaurant offers a fusion of Asian and Mediterranean flavors. Lola 41’s menu showcases a wide array of sushi rolls, sashimi, and other Japanese delights with a creative twist. The lively atmosphere and craft cocktails make it the perfect spot for an evening filled with good food and company.

Nantucket’s culinary scene is a melting pot of flavors that caters to all taste buds. Whether you are a seafood lover, a fan of Italian cuisine, or simply looking for a cozy spot to enjoy a comforting meal, the island offers an impressive array of eateries. This guide to the best eateries in Nantucket for 2019 will surely help you embark on a delightful culinary journey, making your visit to this charming island even more memorable.